Full Time MBA Batch of 2009. NYU Stern School of Business. This is my tryst with an MBA.


Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Monday, November 17, 2008

No to Detroit?

Interesting article by Prof. Yermack on the auto industry and his perspective on the same. Academically sound and theoretically the right thing to do. Practically, impossible that Democrats will allow anyone to go down this road, especially after all the promises that have been made to this effect.

As usual, a question that I ask: Why did they not think when Lehman Brothers was going under. It could have saved them so much grief.

Produced below in verbatim from the Wall Street Journal.

NOVEMBER 15, 2008 Essay
Just Say No to Detroit
Given the abysmal performance by Detroit's Big Three, it would be better to send each employee a check than to waste it on a bailout, says David Yermack.

Before Michael Moore became famous for documentaries like "Fahrenheit 9/11" and "Sicko," his first big success came in 1989 with "Roger and Me." In that film, Mr. Moore followed General Motors chairman and chief executive Roger Smith with a camera crew, asking him why the company was closing plants and producing low-quality vehicles. Mr. Smith looked flustered and inartfully avoided Mr. Moore's camera crew while it lingered outside his country club or GM's executive offices.

Debating the Bailout "Roger and Me" was entertaining, but it missed the real story about Roger Smith, who turned out to be a forward-thinking genius. Mr. Smith made big investments in information technology and satellite communications, acquiring Electronic Data Systems in 1984 for $2.5 billion and Hughes Aircraft in 1985 for $5.2 billion. Mr. Smith's successors divested those businesses at huge profits -- EDS was taken public in 1996 for more than $27 billion, and Hughes, renamed DirecTV, went public in 2003 for more than $23 billion. (The man who sold EDS to Roger Smith at a bargain price was H. Ross Perot, who then convinced many people that the experience qualified him to be president.)

Mr. Smith understood all too well that GM shouldn't continue investing in its failing automobile business. That was 25 years ago. Today, our government is being asked to put tens of billions of dollars in GM, Ford and Chrysler, but we would be much better off if Washington allowed these companies to go bankrupt and disappear.

In 1993, the legendary economist Michael Jensen gave his presidential address to the American Finance Association. Mr. Jensen's presentation included a ranking of which U.S. companies had made the most money-losing investments during the decade of the 1980s. The top two companies on his list were General Motors and Ford, which between them had destroyed $110 billion in capital between 1980 and 1990, according to Mr. Jensen's calculations.

I was a student in Mr. Jensen's business-school class around that time, and one day he put those rankings on the board and shouted "J'accuse!" He wanted his students to understand that when a company makes money-losing investments, the cost falls upon all of society. Investment capital represents our limited stock of national savings, and when companies spend it badly, our future well-being is compromised. Mr. Jensen made his presentation more than 15 years ago, and even then it seemed obvious that the right strategy for GM would be to exit the car business, because many other companies made better vehicles at lower cost.

Roger Smith, who retired as chairman in 1990, seemed to understand that all too well, and so did Chrysler's management, which happily sold their company to Daimler Benz for $30.5 billion in 1998. That deal, one of the savviest corporate divestitures ever, ended very badly for Daimler, which essentially paid Cerberus a few billion dollars (by agreeing to retain pension liabilities) to take Chrysler off its hands in 2007.

Over the past decade, the capital destruction by GM has been breathtaking, on a greater scale than documented by Mr. Jensen for the 1980s. GM has invested $310 billion in its business between 1998 and 2007. The total depreciation of GM's physical plant during this period was $128 billion, meaning that a net $182 billion of society's capital has been pumped into GM over the past decade -- a waste of about $1.5 billion per month of national savings. The story at Ford has not been as adverse but is still disheartening, as Ford has invested $155 billion and consumed $8 billion net of depreciation since 1998.

As a society, we have very little to show for this $465 billion. At the end of 1998, GM's market capitalization was $46 billion and Ford's was $71 billion. Today both firms have negligible value, with share prices in the low single digits. Both are facing imminent bankruptcy and delisting from the major stock exchanges. Along with management, the companies' unions and even their regulators in Washington may have their own culpability, a topic that merits its own separate discussion. Yet one can only imagine how the $465 billion could have been used better -- for instance, GM and Ford could have closed their own facilities and acquired all of the shares of Honda, Toyota, Nissan and Volkswagen.

The implications of this story for Washington policy makers are obvious. Investing in the major auto companies today would be throwing good money after bad. Many are suggesting that $25 billion of public money be immediately injected into the auto business in order to buy time for an even larger bailout to be organized. We would do better to set this money on fire rather than using it to keep these dying firms on life support, setting them up for even more money-losing investments in the future.

Two main arguments are being raised to justify a government rescue of the auto industry. First, large numbers of jobs may be at stake, perhaps as many as three million if one counts all the other firms that supply the Big Three. This greatly overstates the situation. Americans are not going to stop driving cars, and if GM, Ford and Chrysler disappear, other companies will expand to soak up their market share, adding jobs in the process. Many suppliers will also stay in business to satisfy the residual demand for spare parts even if the Detroit manufacturers go under. If the government wants to spend $25 billion to protect auto workers, it would do better to transfer the money to them directly (perhaps by cutting each worker a check for $10,000) rather than by keeping their unproductive employer in business.

Second, it is suggested that the failures of the U.S. financial industry, which have cost us something like $700 billion, justify bailouts of other sectors of the economy. This makes no sense. If the government diverts our national savings into businesses that have long track records of destroying investment capital, eventually we'll end up with an economy like France's -- or Zimbabwe's.

Other arguments are on the table as well. Some see the troubles at GM and Ford as opportunities to retool the auto industry to produce environmentally friendly cars. Given their long track records of lobbying against fuel economy standards and producing oversized gas guzzlers, this suggestion seems ridiculous, sort of like asking cigarette companies to help with cancer research.

Not many of my students today remember "Roger and Me" (many confuse the film with another picture from the same era about the cartoon character Roger Rabbit). However, Roger Smith's example casts a long shadow over the auto industry today. It's time to cut our losses and let society's scarce investment capital flow to an industry with more long-term potential to create jobs and economic value.

David Yermack is a professor of finance at New York University's Stern School of Business.

Scrap the car

Interesting article by Ed Altman on what he thinks to be the future of General Motors and how it should be handled.

I had an interesting discussion with Prof. Roy Smith after my Global Banking class on what he thought to be the way forward for General Motors. I am happy to have access to professors such as him who have a thorough and indepth understanding of the matters at hand. I am sure that he will soon publish his views in the press and hence will not divulge the details of our conversation.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Using knowledge Effectively

Over the past one year, I have learnt a lot at business school. As a Finance and Accounting major, obviously those aspects of the business. Besides that, I have also learnt a lot about Business Strategy, Marketing and Operations. However, that knowledge is useless, unless you know how to use it effectively. Here is an account of the one chance that I got to use this information for personal gain.

I needed to transfer cash from my home country. I have an education loan that takes care of living expenses and I replenish it periodically depending on my own needs. Close to more than a month back, I saw that my funds were dipping low and I needed to get some more money. I also saw that the exchange rate to the dollar was much higher than it was in recent memory.

The US dollar has been appreciating since the FED rates have been dropping in this country [the US]. This has also been accentuated in a way by the increase in interest rates by the central bank in my own country as it attempts to fight the rising levels of inflation in the country. Inflation there is currently higher than it has been in recent memory, a classic case of the workings of supply and demand. The demand for food and foodgrains has increased, and has not been met with corresponding supply in recent times. A drop in supply, combined with astute [and illegal] black marketeering by business(wo)men have ensured that inflation is significantly high.

Then there is the effect of oil prices. Oil has ensured that the local inflation rate in my country has gone higher. This also indirectly affects other prices as it shoots up transportation costs at all levels of the marketplace. Oil prices has also ensured that the demand for the US dollar is higher and that has appreciated the dollar even further, making it more expensive to buy.

When I thought about asking for money, I astutely [in my belief] thought that this was a bubble waiting to burst. Oil prices were at unsustainable levels. With the winter arriving, there was no way that the US could afford to go into a oil-guzzling-heater weather at such expensive levels. There had to be a decrease. Also, with the price of gasoline at such high levels, demand had predictably dropped as people moved to restricting its usage. Ford and GM, promoters of the guzzlers in the US reported huge drops in demand for their SUVs and vans as the US general public moved to cleaner, greener cars.

The OPEC also noticed a sudden drop in the demand for oil. This was accompanied by loud rhetoric to explore and exploit alternative sources of energy which would reduce the dependence on oil, bring prices down and be more environmentally friendly. Suddenly you had Barack H. Obama, John McCain and even Paris Hilton commenting on their green policies. You saw legendary investor T. Boone Pickens coming out with the PickensPlan with a strong focus on wind energy as the source of the future.

Having followed companies in the alternative energy industry space myself, I saw the importance and relevance of solar, wind and other alternative energy companies. The OPEC saw it too. They saw this as a potential drop in the demand of their mainstay product. This warranted even Hugo Chavez, the Venezualian premier who has been trying hook, nail and sinker to ensure higher prices of oil, to comment that oil prices were not sustainable at these levels.

As you must have guessed, I predicted with fair certainty that oil prices were almost certainly going to drop. Levels were not real and then had to get to a sense of normalcy. Midway through the time that elapsed, economists at major investment banks and financial gurus began to chant this mantra as well. I followed USO, an ETF on the American Stock Exchange [AMEX:USO] very closely and found it to be behaving as previously predicted.

I was of the belief that if oil dropped as was predicted [and corroborated by the gurus], this would reduce the demand for the US Dollar. This would also drop the inflation rates in my country [to some extent, this could be lagging or stuck in govt. bureaucracy]. The net effect would be a depreciation of the US dollar to my own local currency and that would buy me more dollars for the same amount of money.

I held out, not telling my parents the real reason. I also thought that it was unlikely that the dollar would appreciate any more than it currently had. It was unlikely to go any stronger. In a way, I did take a bet; a bet in a situation that I should not have taken one [ as a debt ridden b-school student, you dont want to take one]. Yet, as I saw it, it was better to do this than to leave myself to chance. In a normal situation, I would have taken the prevelant rates and transferred the money without giving it a second thought. Atleast this way, I was better informed that there was a higher likelihood of the prices going lower than going higher.

The bet paid off. I waited until I could no longer hold out and needed the money. After that, I asked for the money to be transferred. A net gain of 400 basis points. Not a lot some would say, but then again, it was something. You really cannot expect to make that much of a bet on such non-volatile instruments in such a short period of time anyway.

I am just happy that the knowledge at business school is helping me think like a real business leader who makes his/her decisions based on the prevelant conditions in the market.

For all those undecided, take the plunge. B-school will be the single best investment that you can make in yourselves [ short of getting married rich :-D ]